Prepared. And Still Blindsided.


Issue 007 | November 17, 2026

Prepared for the Review. Not the Conversation.

THE BRIEF

I remember walking into a performance review with an employee who was doing very good work.

She knew her industry, understood marketing, took ownership of her responsibilities, and was making meaningful contributions to the business.

I was prepared to recognize her performance, discuss what I expected from her moving forward, and communicate her merit increase.

In my mind, this was going to be a positive conversation.

But that wasn’t the conversation she was expecting.

When I shared her merit increase, she challenged it. She explained that when she was hired, she had been promised a performance review and a subsequent salary adjustment. She had received an earlier raise, but the additional commitment hadn’t been fulfilled. The increase I was presenting wasn’t what she believed she had been promised.

I knew nothing about that agreement.

Her hiring had taken place under unusual circumstances, and there were expectations established that hadn’t been communicated to me. While I could point to the information HR hadn’t shared, I also had to acknowledge my own responsibility.

As her manager, I should have known.

What followed was a difficult conversation. She was frustrated, and I was caught off guard. I had prepared to discuss her performance and the increase I was authorized to communicate. I hadn’t prepared to address an unresolved expectation that was shaping how she understood the entire review.

I suggested we address the compensation issue separately because she was bringing forward information I needed to understand before we could determine what could be done.

We had both walked into that room prepared. We just weren’t prepared for the same conversation.

TWO PEOPLE. TWO DIFFERENT CONVERSATIONS.

Think about the last time you prepared for an important conversation at work.

You probably spent time thinking about what you wanted to say. You organized your thoughts, gathered examples, and considered how to make your point.

That’s preparation, but it’s only one part of it.

The other person is entering the conversation with their own information, expectations, concerns, and assumptions. Some may be different from yours. Others may be things you don’t know about at all.

In my employee’s case, I believed we were discussing her performance and a merit increase. She believed we were also addressing a commitment made when she joined the organization.

Neither of us had established that difference before the meeting.

What I intended as recognition of her work was received through the frustration of an expectation that hadn’t been met.

Preparing what you want to say doesn’t mean you’re prepared for the conversation the other person expects to have.

Performance reviews make this particularly important because the stakes are personal. People enter these conversations with expectations about their performance, compensation, development, and future opportunities. Yet those expectations aren’t always communicated or understood.

THE CONVERSATION STARTS BEFORE THE MEETING

Here’s something I’ve learned from being on both sides of performance reviews: the formal meeting shouldn’t be the first time important expectations are discussed.

If you’re expecting a promotion, a compensation adjustment, or a change in responsibilities, it’s important to understand whether your manager knows that’s what you’re working toward.

And knowing isn’t the same as agreeing.

Your manager may support your development but have a different understanding of your readiness. They may recognize your contributions but have limited authority over compensation decisions. Or they may simply not know about a commitment made before they became your manager.

These differences influence what each person believes the conversation is supposed to accomplish.

Of course, not every difficult conversation can be prevented. Sometimes you discover information you couldn’t reasonably have anticipated. Sometimes the other person brings a perspective you disagree with.

But preparing for a conversation means making room for those possibilities.

It requires you to think beyond the points you want to deliver and consider what you need to understand from the other person.

It also means recognizing when the conversation has changed.

In my case, continuing to explain the merit increase would not have addressed the real issue. I needed to understand the commitment my employee was referring to before we could determine what should happen next.

When new information changes the conversation, your preparation needs to help you respond, not keep you attached to your original talking points.

TRY THIS: PREPARE FOR BOTH SIDES

Before your next performance review, don’t stop once you’ve completed your self-evaluation.

Take a few minutes to consider three questions.

1. What do I need my manager to understand?

Identify the most important message you want to communicate about your performance, contributions, or development.

This isn’t about presenting every accomplishment. It’s about being clear on what matters most.

2. What do I need to understand from my manager?

Consider where your perspectives might differ.

Are you clear on how your performance is being evaluated? Do you understand what your manager considers strong performance? Are there expectations you haven’t discussed?

Prepare questions that will help you understand their perspective rather than assuming you already know it.

3. What expectations need to be addressed before the review?

Think about commitments, concerns, or aspirations that could influence the conversation.

If you’re expecting a promotion or compensation adjustment, have you discussed it with your manager? Do you understand how those decisions are made and when they happen?

You don’t need to resolve every issue before your review. But you shouldn’t assume that an important expectation is understood simply because it’s clear to you.

WHAT IF THE CONVERSATION GOES IN A DIFFERENT DIRECTION?

Even with preparation, you may hear something you didn’t expect.

Your manager may raise a concern, disagree with your assessment, or introduce information that changes your understanding of the situation.

When that happens, you don’t have to respond immediately to everything you’re hearing.

You can acknowledge the information, ask questions to understand it, and determine whether you have enough context to continue productively.

Sometimes the most effective thing you can say is:

“I wasn’t aware of that. I’d like to understand it better before we decide how to move forward.”

That isn’t avoiding the conversation. It’s recognizing that you need clarity before you can have a useful one.

Looking back, I wish I had entered that performance review with a better understanding of my employee’s expectations. It was my responsibility as her manager to ask questions and uncover information that could affect the discussion.

I also wish those expectations had been raised earlier, when we had more time to understand the situation and explore what could be done.

Neither of us benefited from discovering that gap during the formal review.

The same lesson applies when you’re the employee sitting on the other side of the table.

Your performance review is an opportunity to communicate your perspective, understand someone else’s, and clarify what happens next.

As you prepare, ask yourself whether you’ve spent as much time thinking about the conversation you need to have as you have preparing the points you want to make.

Don’t prepare only to deliver your message.

Prepare to have a conversation.

WANT TO PUT THIS INTO PRACTICE?

If you’re preparing for a performance review and want to communicate your contributions with greater clarity, join me for Communicate Your Value, a live workshop on December 15.

We’ll work on how to explain the impact of your work, communicate what you want next, and prepare for the conversations that matter to your career.

Enrollment is now open.

Sign Up: Communicate Your Value​

Until next time,

Natasha

The Alignment Brief

The Alignment Brief is for leaders who want to communicate more clearly at work. Each week, Natasha breaks down the conversations, decisions, and misunderstandings that slow work down, with practical ideas to help people understand, align, and move forward.

Read more from The Alignment Brief

Issue 006 | November 10, 2026 Your Work Doesn’t Always Speak for Itself THE BRIEF When I was working for Mattel in Hong Kong, I reached a point in my career when I began to understand that doing the work and communicating its value were two very different things. I was a manager at the time, although the title carried significantly more responsibility in Asia than it typically does in the United States. I had substantial business and P&L responsibilities, worked closely with regional...

Issue 005 | November 3, 2026 You Got the Feedback. Now What? THE BRIEF Early in my career, I walked into a performance review feeling good about the work I'd done. My manager praised my presentation skills, how I handled situations, the improvements I'd made to our weekly reporting, and the progress we'd made in the department. I'd also made it clear that I wanted to grow within the organization. I was ambitious, eager to take on more responsibility, and interested in what it would take to...

Issue 004 | October 27, 2026 The Conversation Nobody Wants to Have THE BRIEF When I was working in Hong Kong, we were building a regional operation that hadn’t existed in quite the same way before. We were figuring things out as we went, testing approaches, making adjustments, and learning what worked across markets that were very different from one another. This was around 2013 and 2014, when digital marketing was evolving rapidly. The markets we managed were developing digital behaviors and...